Head Transplants and Other Ethical Dilemmas from 2015
University of Notre Dame releases its fourth annual survey on pressing policy issues in science and technology. Continue reading →
From artificial wombs to head transplants, the real-world science issues we see in the headlines just get weirder every year. What used to be the domain of pulp fiction sci-fi is now taking up pages in the peer-reviewed journals.
This week, the John J. Reilly Center for Science, Technology, and Values at the University of Notre Dame released its annual list of emerging ethical dilemmas and policy issues in science and technology.
The Reilly Center, dedicated to cross-disciplinary discussion of scientific policy issues, has identified 10 worrisome developments that arose in 2015 and that should be watched closely in the coming year.
Genetic engineering, as one might expect, continues to be an area of concern. The Reilly Center's top ten list - presented in no particular order - includes two separate issues related to genetics: the gene editing technology known as CRISPR, and the diagnostic technique of rapid whole genome sequencing.
Also flagged for 2016 is the visually evocative issue of head transplants, which at least one physician is preparing to undertake by 2017. The Reilly report cites "myriad and almost inconceivable" ethical issues around the proposed procedure, which would call into question fundamental issues of identity.
The controversial research area of ectogenesis - or artificial wombs - is cited for its profound social implications in medicine, bioethics and reproductive politics. The report also raises intriguing questions on idea of outfitting people with exoskeletons for use in manual labor.
Other issues raised in the report concern digital labor rights, drones (naturally), and the use of bone conduction technology for piping advertisements directly into consumer's skulls. Then there is the matter of Hello Barbie.
The Reilly Center's list of emerging ethical dilemmas is complied with the help of Reilly researchers, other Notre Dame experts and friends of the center. You can get more details at the Reilly Top 10 project page, which features overview discussions along with hyperlinked citations to news reports and scientific journals.
Dr. Tom Frieden, director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), told Discovery News that "2015 was a very active year for protecting Americans." Indeed, there were plenty of crises and near-crises that threatened our health. Here's a sampling of six scares from 2015. In the meantime, the World Health Organization has alreadyissued a list of the top diseases on its watchlist
for 2016. For the second year, Ebola dominated global health issues. At the CDC, over 4,000 staff members, or 20 percent of the staff, worked on curtailing the outbreak, Frieden said. "The thing that is least well understood about Ebola is how close it became to a global catastrophe," Frieden said. "It could have been widespread in Africa for years, and it would have killed people not just from Ebola, but because health systems stop functioning." In fact, in Guinea,more people died of malaria than Ebola
, because the country's health care system was so overloaded with Ebola patients that people with other diseases couldn't get proper treatment. "Ebola is an epidemic that not only kills but undermines others," Frieden said.10 Things That Kill the Ebola Virus
Over 15,000 Americans died from
) in a single year; it causes more hospital-acquired infections than any other bacteria, according to a CDC study. Not only do people often contract it when they are on antibiotics; some strains are resistant to treatment from antibiotics, making fecal transplants the leading alternative treatment. But the scariest bacteria news of 2015 might be the recent finding that a superbug gene found in China quickly infected someone in Denmark, highlighting the risk that drug-resistant bacteria pose to most modern medicine. "I'm an infectious disease physician and I have treated many people with cancer who are getting chemotherapy and have had horrible infections held in check with antibiotics," Frieden said. "If we don't have antibiotics, then cancer and other [modern medical treatments] are hanging by a thread." Waiting for a new miracle drug is a mistake, he added; it's also essential to take "better stewardship of the antibiotics we have."New Resistant Superbug Spreading
Air pollution is a silent killer, said Dr. Francesca Dominici, a professor of biostatistics at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health. But there's no escaping it. "With air, you cannot wake up one morning and say you're not going to breathe or even move somewhere with clean air," she said. "It's affecting everybody." There is an antidote, however: "If we shut down coal-fired power plants, it would save lives immediately," she said. "But it's the one thing no one is talking about." Climate change talk tends to focus on the future, what life will be like in 100 years. But there is a "health crisis happening right now," she said, and "it's crazy to think people are not doing anything about it. In a certain way, not acting on air quality and power plants is like not acting on the Ebola epidemic." When coal-fired power plants are shut down, the ambient air improves immediately, she said. Air pollution is linked to cardiovascular disease, which is the No. 1 killer in the U.S. It's also associated with lung function and cognitive issues in children.Air Pollution in China Kills Millions Annually
Although it didn't cause any deaths, the measles outbreak traced to Disneyland grabbed headlines across the country and put the debate about vaccines back in the spotlight. Many of the 147 people who fell sick were not immunized against measles, either for personal beliefs or because they were too young to get the vaccine. Vaccines in the U.S. are "underused," Frieden said. Take the HPV vaccine, which is recommended for girls and boys at age 11 or 12: according to a 2014 survey, 40 percent of girls and 60 percent of boys hadn't started the 3-shot series. "We're doing less well that Rwanda at protecting our children against HPV," he said. About 25 percent of Americans are infected with HPV, which can cause several types of cancer.5 Disease Outbreaks Linked to Vaccine-Shy Parents
Each year, more than 200,000 people die from preventable medical errors, killing more Americans than anything except for heart disease and cancer. "Considering we're all going to get sick at some point and need a hospital, it's hard to think we could suffer from error, and care that is not coordinated as it should be," Dominici said. Errors include everything from giving patients the wrong medication to giving premature babies too much oxygen.Mistakes Made In Half of All Surgeries
When 180 people in one small town in Indiana were infected with HIV in less than a year, it drew national attention. In a county that typically sees fewer than five cases of HIV a year, most of the new cases were linked to partners injecting the prescription opioid oxymorphone with shared syringes. Opioid pain relievers are prescribed for reducing severe pain, but "we got the risk-benefit wrong," Frieden said. "There's a short-term benefit, but in the medium- and long-term, you could die from it." The painkillers are so addictive that 1.9 million Americans live with prescription opioid abuse or dependence, and there are thousands of overdose deaths in the U.S. per year. The 2015 Indiana State Department of Health investigation reveals additional risks, including a resurgence of HIV.Video: Big Leap Toward HIV Cure