Deadly Sponges Snuffing-Out Coral Colonies
Sponges are using toxins, mucus, shading and smothering to kill and then take over coral colonies in areas that have been over-fished, finds a new study.
It sounds like the plot of a B-movie, but researchers have determined that sponges in over-fished areas are using deadly tactics - such as smothering and toxic mucus - to kill coral colonies so that the sponges can grow on what's left: skeletons.
The discovery shows how disruption of even just a few members of an ecosystem - in this case, tasty fish - can hurt many other organisms that live in the same area.
The problem, highlighted in the latest issue of the journal PeerJ, is particularly evident at Caribbean coral reefs, where the combined effects of warming seawater temperatures, storms, and diseases have already decimated populations of corals.
While coral looks sort of like an undersea plant, groupings actually consist of tiny marine creatures that live together within compact colonies. They usually grow slowly. Sponges, on the other hand, grow either quickly or more slowly, depending on the species.
"If the goal is to save the corals that build Caribbean reefs, we have to protect the angelfishes and parrotfishes that eat sponges," lead author Tse-Lynn Loh, now a Postdoctoral Research Associate at the Haerther Center for Conservation and Research at Chicago's Shedd Aquarium, said in a press release.
Loh and colleagues surveyed reefs from 12 countries across the Caribbean. The scientists compared 25 sites where fish abundance is very low (because of decades of intensive fish trapping) with 44 sites where fishes are plentiful (because they've been protected from fishermen).
Both fast and slow-growing sponges tended to dominate coral colonies at overfished sites, adversely impacting at least 25 percent of them. The damage was more than double the incidence of this seen at less-fished reefs. At the latter, angelfishes and parrotfishes munched on the sponges, helping to keep their dominant ways in check.
Even when the fish were around, slower-growing sponges still made a dent in coral colonies, since these sponges can unleash their arsenal of "weapons" that allow them to compete aggressively for reef real estate. In addition to the smothering tactics and toxic mucus, the sponges can kill coral by releasing other toxins and by shading out light.
In past studies, seaweed was also found to hurt coral, but the new research led to the surprising discovery that seaweeds were more abundant on reefs with greater numbers of fish. The outcome is contrary to the conventional wisdom that fishes eat seaweeds and keep them in check. It now looks like the relationship between seaweeds and fishes is more complicated than previously imagined.
Conservationists in earlier years based some of their claims about needed regulation of fishing at reefs on the idea that fish kept damaging seaweed under control. Now, there is convincing evidence that sponges, and perhaps not so much seaweed, are heavily impacted by over-fishing, which sets the stage for the sponges to kill and take over coral reefs.
"Caribbean nations can now base their fishing policy decisions on the clear connection between overfishing and sponge-smothered corals," said co-author Joseph Pawlik of the University of North Carolina at Wilmington. "Coral conservation requires a healthy population of reef fishes."
Brain coral (Diploria labyrinthiformis) overgrown and smothered by the lavender branching sponge Aplysina cauliformis.
The Ocean Art Underwater Photo Competition, organized by the Underwater Photography Guide, announces its 2013 winners. Here, a triggerfish is being cleaned at a wreck in the Red Sea.
Two kelp crabs defend their meal in waters off of Seattle.
This scene might look intimate, but these fish are actually fighting. Two blennies lock jaws near Blue Heron Bridge in Riviera Beach, Fla.
Two green sea turtles meet up at Tenerife, the largest of the seven Canary Islands.
Two manatee calves nurse in a family moment snapped at Crystal River, Fla.
This sea lion portrait was captured in Southern Australia.
A bait ball refers to a naturally occurring fish swarm. This diver in the Canary Islands certainly had a good view of one.
Blacktip sharks are active at dusk, as you can see in this shot of a shark near KwaZulu Natal, a province of South Africa.
Photographer Vanessa Mignon went eye-to-eye with a humpback whale near Vava’u, Tonga.
Water appears to be spinning around this Caribbean reef shark, photographed in the Bahamas.
Dolphins will sometimes eat jellyfish, but this enormous one doesn't appear to be on the dolphin’s menu.
The photographer moved in for a close-up of this squid in the waters off of northeast Taiwan.
The flower-like hydroid is actually a small marine predator related to jellyfish. Tiny crustaceans known as amphipods collect around the hydroid. They were photographed off Grand Cayman.
This pipefish makes contact with coral near Moalboal, Philippines.
Juveniles of many marine species stick together, like these flying fish. They were captured near the water’s surface off northeast Taiwan.
The pink of the algae really pops over a school of parrotfish in the waters off of Socorro Island.
"The tiny octopus stopped in my lights, intently studying me as I studied it," said photographer Jeffrey Millsen, "and then began to expressively posture and react to my every move."
This grey seal was timid at first, but couldn’t resist playing with the diver’s drysuit glove. The moment was captured in the waters off of Norway.
Red hues often signify danger in nature. This devil scorpionfish seems to be basking in its power, hanging out at Lembeh Strait, Indonesia.
A man takes his child for a first dip.