For the study, each participant was asked to stand in a noise-insulated room and identify whether or not a wooden disc had been placed in the room. In the real world, echolocators move their heads from side-to-side sending clicks in a variety of different directions, in the same way that a person visually scans a room.
But in this case, the researchers asked the participants to keep their heads straight ahead while clicking. Thaler said that she and her team weren’t trying to understand whether the blind person could identify where the disc was, but simply how they used their clicks to detect it.
The wooden disc, about 7 inches in diameter, was attached to a thin metal rod, which was half a centimeter thick. The disc acted as a sound reflector, and at random intervals was placed either in front of the person, or at 45, 90, 135, or 180-degree angles relative to the person’s face. Each time the pole and disc were moved, the participant was asked to cover his or her ears and hum so that they could not hear the movement.
Once the disc was in place, the researchers tapped the participant on the ankle using a very long rod, giving the cue to start clicking. Tiny microphones attached to near the participants ears recorded the clicks and echoes used to locate the disc.
All eight participants correctly identified the presence of the disc 100 percent of the time when it was placed in front of them and at 45 and 90-degree angles. It took some people just one click and others between three and five clicks to identify the disk. The loudness of the clicks was between 74 and 76 decibels — about as loud as an average conversation.
RELATED: Auditory Experiments Suggest the Right Ear Is the Better Listener
When placed slightly behind them at a 135-degree angle, participants guessed its presence about 80 percent of the time, needed between 8 and 10 clicks, and increased the loudness to about 80 decibels. When placed behind them at 180 degrees, participants guessed correctly about 50 percent of the time, used between 9 and 12 clicks, and increased the loudness to about 84 decibels.
In short, when the disc was placed at further angles, each person had to work harder to find it. They modulated the intensity and the number of clicks, thereby adjusting the signal-to-noise ratio — the signal being the echo and the noise being any ambient sound. Their brains were essentially gathering audio samples over time, perhaps averaging them out to come up with a yes or no answer.
Although she said she doesn’t know what drives this process, Thaler thinks that the principles that the brain uses to govern how information is collected for echolocation are likely the same principles that it uses for sight or touch.
“These echo experts have trained themselves and obviously their auditory systems have adapted very well. It’s an example of what the human brain can do if you just put your mind to it,” said Thaler.