'Ugly Duckling' Pteranodons Floated, But Poorly
Sept. 15, 2011 --
A stunning array of prehistoric feathers, including dinosaur protofeathers, has been discovered in Late Cretaceous amber from Canada. The 78 to 79-million-year-old amber preserved the feathers in vivid detail, including some of their diverse colors. The collection, published in this week's Science, is among the first to reveal all major evolutionary stages of feather development in non-avian dinosaurs and birds. In this slide, an isolated barb from a vaned feather is visible trapped within a tangled mass of spider's web.
BLOG: 40-Million-Year-Old Sex Act Captured in Amber
"These specimens were most likely blown into the tacky resin, or were plucked from an animal as it brushed against resin on a tree trunk," lead author Ryan McKellar told Discovery News. "The fact that we have found some specimens trapped within spider webs in the amber would suggest that wind played an important role in bringing the feathers into contact with the resin," added McKellar, a postdoctoral fellow at the University of Alberta's Department of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences. The feather filaments shown here are similar to protofeathers that have been associated with some dinosaur skeletons.
NEWS: Cretaceous African Life Sealed in Amber
McKellar and his team made the discovery after screening over 4,000 amber samples from Grassy Lake, Alberta. The amber, collected by the Leuck family, is now housed at the Royal Tyrrell Museum. The researchers ruled out that the inclusions were mammal hairs, plant or fungal remains based on their structure. Some dinosaur fossils retain skin impressions, so the scientists could match dinosaur protofeathers (hair-like projections) to some of the objects within the amber. Here, a feather is visible near a plant bug. The high number of coils in the this feather suggests it could have come from a water-diving bird.
The translucent tree resin provides a window into feather evolution, from non-avian dinosaurs to birds. "Part of what makes this particular set of feathers interesting is that we find the very simple Stage I and II feathers alongside advanced feathers that are very similar to those of modern birds, Stages IV and V," McKellar said. The researchers aren't yet certain why feathers first evolved, but the density of the protofeathers suggests that they helped dinosaurs with regulating temperature. Dinosaurs such as Troodon or Deinonychus may have produced the feathers. The cork-screw shaped structures in this slide are the tightly coiled bases of feather barbules.
As feathers continued to change, they developed tufts, barbs, branching features, little hooks, and more. Some of the most advanced feathers in the collection are comparable to those of modern grebes. They appear to help diving, indicating that some of the prehistoric birds were divers. McKellar suspects the marine birds might have been Hesperornithiformes, a specialized flightless diving bird from the Dinosaur Era. This is a white belly feather of a modern grebe, showing coiled bases comparable to those seen in the Cretaceous specimen.
Some of the feathers appear transparent now, but would have been white in life. A range of colors for the feathers is evident, though, with grays, reds and various shades of brown preserved. This, and prior research, suggests that non-avian dinosaurs and prehistoric birds could be quite flashy. The pigment within this fossilized feather suggests it would have originally been medium- or dark-brown in color.
NEWS: Dino's True Colors Revealed by Tail Feathers
In an accompanying "Perspectives" article in Science, Mark Norell points out that the dinosaur Sinosauropteryx is thought to have had a reddish banded tail, while Anchiornis likely possessed a striking black body, banded wings and a reddish head comb. Norell, chair and curator of the American Museum of Natural History's Division of Paleontology, told Discovery News that the newly discovered feathers are "very exciting." Here, a feather barb within Late Cretaceous Canadian amber shows some indication of original coloration.
Some dino aficionados have wondered if DNA could be extracted from the feathers. "Almost anything is possible," Norell said, quickly adding that most DNA-extraction studies have been conducted on much younger amber, dating to around 20-30 million years ago, and even those led to questionable results. "Maybe bits and pieces could be identified, but not the whole genome." Shown are 16 clumped feathers in Late Cretaceous amber.
People with amber objects, such as jewelry, also probably don't have prehistoric feather inclusions, since such items are extremely rare and dealers isolate the best pieces. Nevertheless, McKellar said, "There is some hope that you could have small feather fragments that have been overlooked." An unpigmented feather and a mite in Canadian Late Cretaceous amber.
It might have been the ugliest duckling ever, but scientists using Canada geese for a model have determined that pteranodons, ancient flying reptiles, probably floated on water but not so prettily as their modern avian counterparts.
Like modern birds, the pteranodon had hollow bones, which would have made them light and buoyant. There is also evidence that the flying reptiles foraged in watery environments. But it takes computational modeling to work out exactly how they might have managed to float on water without drowning.
“This isn't about swimming. This isn't about diving,” clarified David Hone of Queen Mary University of London, who coauthored a paper on the work with Donald Henderson of Canada's Royal Terrell Museum of Paleontology. It's just about how the pteranodons floated.
First the researchers tested their flotation model by reproducing the depth and position of a floating Canada goose. Then they tried to make it work for a pteranodon, shifting different variables around just to make certain they covered most possible poses for the flying reptiles in the water. What they found was that the creatures probably didn't sit well on the water surface. In fact they barely could keep their mouths above the water.
“A good analogy is a human,” Hone explained. “If I just lie in a swimming pool I barely have my mouth above the water.” And any waves would make it extremely hard to breathe.
But that does not mean pteranodons were bad at foraging in water, any more than it means humans can't swim, Hone said.
“It isn't necessarily a problem,” Hone said, citing modern birds that spend much of their lives over the ocean but are rather poor at floating on the surface. “Pterosaurs are the Cretaceous albatross.”
Other researchers who have modeled behaviors of pteranodon agree that the posture in the water is not a problem.
“I'm glad they put it in the water, said Sankar Chatterjee of Texas Tech University. “I was really surprised by the way the wings are really like a sail.”
Hone and Henderson published their work in the Dec. 1 issue of the journal Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology. Their abstract can be found here.