A The College of Wooster
The top 10 largest terrestrial animals on Earth were all dinosaurs, and a new analysis of dinosaur fossils reveals the biggest of the big.
The new study, published in the journal Scientific Reports, determined that the most gargantuan dinosaurs were all herbivores.
“Sauropod dinosaurs -- long-necked plant eaters -- include the largest land animals that have ever existed," lead author Kenneth Lacovara of Drexel University told Discovery News.
“Multiple studies have shown that the body weight of a four-legged animal corresponds closely with measurements taken from its humerus (upper arm bone) and femur (thigh bone)," Lacovara said.
Calculations based on such fossil measurements put Diplodocus longus in the No. 10 spot. The estimated mass (a measure of how much matter is in an individual or object) of this dinosaur is 16.3 tons.
Dmitry Bogdanov, Wikimedia Commons
Weighing in at No. 9 is Giraffitian brancai. Its mass was calculated to be 37.5 tons.
Girth is only one component of size, but the longest dinosaurs tended also to be the heftiest. Lacovara said many such dinosaurs spent their days pursuing “a life-long obsession with eating." Dinosaurs like Giraffitian would devote hour after hour to consuming tree and fern leaves, not moving much from their feasting spots.
Skeleton of Futalognkosaurus Wikimedia Commons
No. 8 on the list is Futalognkosaurus dukei, which had an estimated mass of 42 tons. That's equivalent to 84,000 pounds.
Philip Mannion and Alejandro Otero, Dinopedia
Next in the lineup is Elaltitan lilloi. According to the new study, its mass was 47.2 tons. This dinosaur lived in what is now southern Argentina.
Turiasaurus riodevensis is one of the largest dinosaurs ever to be found in Europe. The dinosaur, which had a mass of 56.1 tons, was excavated in what are now eastern Spain and Portugal.
Weighing in at 62 tons is Brachiosaurus altithorax, which was hailed as “the largest-known dinosaur" by discoverer Elmer Riggs in 1903. While it's No. 5 on the list now, at 62 tons, this dinosaur still made the top 10.
Sauroposeidon proteles was not included in the Scientific Reports study. This species, and the entire genus, are only known from several incomplete specimens. So it's more challenging to accurately estimate its weight and height. Some paleontologists theorize that it weighed anywhere from 55-66 tons. It could, therefore, move even higher on this list should more fossils be found.
Dmitry Bogdanov, Wikimedia Commons
Lacovara and a team of his colleagues discovered Paralititan stromeri in 2001. “We only recovered the humerus of Paralititan, and therefore cannot be sure about its limb proportions," Lacovara told Discovery News.
Based on the fossil that was excavated, however, it was an enormous dinosaur. The humerus, measuring about 5 1/2 feet, is lengthier than that of any other known Cretaceous sauropod. Paralititan is another contender for possible top spot placement on this list if additional fossils are found and support the speculation about its size.
Mark A. Klinger, Carnegie Museum of Natural History
“Dreadnoughtus schrani has the largest reliably calculable weight of any known land animal," Lacovara said. Announcement of its discovery was made just this week, reminding that on any day, new fossil finds could change this list.
The mass of Dreadnoughtus was 65.4 tons. This dinosaur had no known enemies during its lifetime.
Most paleontologists, including Lacovara, believe that Argentinosaurus huinculensis was the world's largest-ever land animal. “I think it is very likely that Argentinosaurus is the most massive dinosaur yet known," Lacovara said. "However, I don't think we can make a reliable estimation of its mass."
He explained that the femur sometimes associated with this species has never formally been referred to in a peer-reviewed journal. Rough estimates by others estimate that Argentinosaurus could have been 115 feet in length with a weight of anywhere from 88–110 tons.